I really love the double-breasted, belted style with zipper detail - I feel like it really cinches in the waist for a flattering silhouette. Another great detail is a zip-up vest sewn into the jacket for extra warmth.
This Gray version is very similar to the black but does not have the belt. I feel like it still fits well but isn't as flattering. I think this may have to go back to the store - what do you think? Keep or return?